Book Review: “Ugly As Sin” by Michael Rose

Catholic churches—how should we build them in this enlightened and sophisticated 21st century?"Ugly As Sin" by Michael Rose

Actually, it’s no mystery. And it’s not up to subjective interpretation: there are principles and plenty of precedent for the construction of Catholic church buildings. Well, if you want to know how we should construct a Catholic church (and perhaps more importantly, how not to do it), you need look no farther than this fascinating book. I bought Ugly As Sin by Michael S. Rose last month out of a catalog for only $5. The full title is Ugly As Sin: Why They Changed Our Churches from Sacred Places to Meeting Spaces—and How We Can Change Them Back Again.

The interested reader of this blog might want to know who the “they” referred to in the title are.  Tragically, and horribile dictu, “they” are the bishops and priests of the last half-century. Although Mr. Rose does not dwell overlong on this particular point, he does explain some of the ideological skullduggery of some U.S. bishops in the late 1970s, their noxious ecclesiastical/architectural ideas, and the immediate consequences of their actions and decisions. Also, he mentions that in the aftermath of the Second Vatican Council a particular American bishop was personally warned by a letter from Vatican officials to respect and maintain the beauty of his cathedral. (Which warning he proceeded to disregard, subsequently dismantling treasured architectural elements of the historic Cathedral at his whim.)

When churches were built or “renovated” (a.k.a. “wreckovated”) in the last fifty years, marble high altars were jack-hammered, Communion rails were ripped out and junked, and sacred statues were thrown into rivers. It makes me sick to think of. Well, we all of us know what they did, because our parish churches are unmistakeable, visible, irrefutable evidence of it. The old churches don’t look like they used to, and the new ones look like spaceships, barns, auditoriums…really anything but churches. So the real question is…why? Why did this happen? Why did they do this?

As always, the poison of wicked ideas was the cause. Among a majority of American clergy the poisonous notions of the church as a fraternal social work organization, inspired by Christ the social reformer, was widely embraced. So they built buildings that were up-to-the-minute fashionable to be meeting places for their social justice clubs. Sacrament and sacrifice, divinity and distribution of grace (God’s life in our souls) was downplayed if not dismissed altogether. It was first a mental and spiritual disembowelment of the Faith, and then they disemboweled the churches, the physical representations of the Faith in wood and stone. Tellingly, American clerics commissioned ideas and advice from such architects as the prolific and progressive Evangelical Lutheran Edward  Sövik. (Mr. Rose traces his ideas and influence in Chapter 4, which is both heart-breaking and enlightening.)

There is so much information in this book. How can we reduce all of it to some easy-to-remember points we can use to talk to and to educate others?  Thankfully, the author gives us an easy template. Mr. Rose says all Catholic churches should (1) have vertical elements reaching to and pointing us toward Heaven, (2) must be made durably and solidly in order to last for centuries, as a sign of the eternal truths of the Faith, and (3) with iconography of all sorts, should display in physical form these same eternal truths.  These points, first laid out for us in Chapter 1, subsequently guide us through the book. These principles inform our evaluation as the author mentally tours a traditionally-styled church building with us, assessing its elements and structure, commenting on its appropriateness as a church, a House of God, in Chapter 2. After that mental examination, in Chapter 3 the author similarly leads us into another building, where we examine a paradigmatic modern church, that “worship space of the people,” in light of the three original principles from the first chapter. As I mentioned above, Chapter 4 goes on to explain some of the history and the bad theology behind the hideous new structures distorting today’s Catholic landscape. And finally Chapter 5 describes what we need to do and what we can do to “make our churches Catholic again”—to make them sacred and devoted to the worship of the Almighty, as He Himself prefers to be worshiped.

As many photographs within the book beautifully witness, even before it was first published in 2001, work had already been going on in the United States to restore wreckovated churches and to revive beauty and sacredness in parishes across the country. Of course, now after the pontificate of our beloved Pope Benedict and the recent explosion of vocations of young and faithful priests, we can see that such efforts have increased and continue, with the support of many concerned laypeople.  If you have the opportunity to help with a restoration in your area, do so! If you can be a voice for the sacredness and beauty of the Catholic Faith in the construction of a new Church in your area, be one! Start by reading this book. Then you’ll be prepared to answer questions and educate others as to what we ought to do and why when building a Catholic church. Such an education has, for me, been worth far more than $5.


2 thoughts on “Book Review: “Ugly As Sin” by Michael Rose

  1. I’m from Israel, so I have no first-hand experience with Christians or Christianity. This was a pretty interesting read, especially how churches became meeting places. I always imaged them (and synagogues) as quiet places where you can go to be alone with yourself and your thoughts. They’re supposed to be a refuge from daily life, not another part of it. How right or wrong am I?

    • Hello! Thank you for your comment, it is very good to hear from someone with a new perspective who is from such an amazing place.
      Church architecture is one of my favorite topics, and one that makes me extremely animated in discussions, so I fear I might give you way too much information. If you bear with me, maybe you will find what you are looking for! 🙂
      Do you know how Catholic beliefs relate to the Jewish tradition? Our Faith comes out of Judaism, and is a fulfillment of it. Therefore, anyone who knows about the Covenant and history of Judaism should be able to recognize a lot in the Catholic Faith.
      A Catholic church building is the place where God himself is present. I know that He was really and spiritually present in the Temple at Jerusalem, until the Temple was destroyed by the Romans. But in Catholic churches, He is present in the tabernacle spiritually and physically: He is present Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. His Presence in each church is reason alone for each one to be a beautiful, sacred, and elevated place, as Solomon made sure his Temple was to honor the Most High.
      But furthermore, churches are where Catholics congregate for a Sacrifice—THE Sacrifice. God became human 2,000 years ago, and He chose to die at human hands as the ultimate atonement for all human sin. He willed this same Sacrifice to be re-presented in an unbloody manner by His followers, until He returns in glory at the end of time. (And that’s why Catholics have a priesthood: because you must have priests for there to be a sacrifice.) A sacred place for the re-presentation of the once-for-all Sacrifice is what the Catholic church building is for—and since nothing, absolutely nothing can be too good for God, Who has done this for us, it must show evidence of being a sacred and holy place. It is a Temple, and not a meeting room for glad-handing and self-congratulation, which is unfortunately what almost all churches in the decadent West have become. It makes me very bitter to think about, but we Catholics have largely lost our faith and our understanding that our services (Holy Mass) are re-presentaions of the Sacrifice. And ugly, theologically unsound architecture is what happens when we lose our Faith.
      Well, that’s a lot of information, I know. I hope it clarifies my thinking on church buildings somewhat. Again, thank you for your comment, and I hope you have a wonderful day (or night), whatever time it is where you are!

Your thoughts:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s